Tag Archives: school

“A woman can’t marry a woman”

Lucy's Kindergarten Class

This morning 5 1/2 year old Lucy told me about a kid in her class who told her last week that a woman can’t marry a woman.  Just as she did in preschool and daycare, she said that she told her friend that’s not true because her mommy and momma are married and she was at their wedding and that she knows marriage is between two adults, a woman and a woman, or a woman and a man, or a man and a man.  She said that her friend told her that her parents’ marriage is not legal, and, this morning, she said, “I know you’re married, and it is legal, right?”

I simply said yes, your parents are legally married.  Otherwise, I would’ve answered her with all of the complications that involve lack of equal rights for our family.  Sure, it’s legal here in California, a handful of other states, and a short list of countries.  No, it’s not legal according to our country’s federal government, a long list of other states, and a long list of other countries.

The first time, that I know of, that she ever responded to the question of why she doesn’t have a dad, or the challenge of “a woman can’t marry a woman,” was when she was a toddler in daycare and one of her friends asked her why she doesn’t have a dad.  She was barely 2 years old, if that, and she told her friend “I have a mommy, momma, and wanda, and you have a mommy, daddy, and dog, and you are missing a momma and a wanda and I am missing a daddy and a dog, so everyone’s missing something.”

Sometime last fall or winter, when Moya and I were in Lucy’s classroom, one of her classmates asked us if we were sisters or cousins.  We said, no, we’re married to each other, we aren’t sisters or cousins.  The kid responded with surprise, “no way! Two women can get married?!”  We shrugged and said yes and left it at that.  The kid seemed happy to know it was a possibility.

I’m glad that Lucy’s figured out on her own to stand up for herself and answer questions about her family as though she’s simply reporting on the weather and I hope she always feels that confident about her family.

Good Intentions

I asked a childhood friend of mine about support for gays and lesbians in the rural area where we grew up and was told:

We have both Middle School and High School support groups for gay and lesbian students. While it is a general expectation that none of the staff focus on issues of their own sexuality, there are several staff who are themselves gay, so that is a built-in channel of support.  In the elementary school, it doesn’t come up very often. A couple of years ago, while going through a workshop on suicide, another counselor and I practiced through a scenario in which she played the role of a gay student in this small town. Pretty much her own life story, really. We talked about finding supports in this small town, as there are some good things in place. We also talked about getting out to a bigger area where she could find more people to lean on who were gay-friendly or gay themselves. I think that was really helpful for me personally to think through the issue in a person-centered way. My early (conservative Christian) upbringing probably would have leaned me toward the same type of counseling you got back in the day, but I hope that I am much closer to the point where I see people like Jesus would.

Come out! Come out!  Everyone needs to share a story like this to help basic human LGBT rights progress.  Telling these stories, however, requires coming out of a closet:  a story about what it’s like to be a gay student, how your family is no different from anyone else just because you have two moms, how your lesbian daughter is just as much of a good upstanding citizen and kind generous person, all of these stories require someone who is not necessarily LGBT (and is usually straight) to open a closet door.

The story above is such an improvement from my experience of attending public school in a rural area and a small town where there was no support for gay and lesbian kids.

For the staff at these schools, I wonder what would qualify as focusing on issues of their own sexuality.  If someone wears a wedding ring, does that indicate something about their sexuality?  If a woman mentions her husband then she has explicitly mentioned something about her sexuality, and I’m pretty sure that is not disallowed.  Usually when people are asked not to discuss their sexuality it’s a specific request for a gay or lesbian person to not mention their significant other.  For example, if I meet someone and mention my wife I’ve automatically implied that I’m a lesbian (or a man who mentions his wife automatically implies that he’s straight).

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

I recently asked a church whether or not it was gay-friendly and why it doesn’t show up on lists of gay-friendly churches. I won’t include the name of the church here because it isn’t relevant.  It further shows how people think they are friendly while, in the same paragraph, describing how my marriage is not as worthy (or even affirmed or acknowledged) as a straight married couple.  I think the person who wrote this to me believes that this is welcoming and friendly (even though the word friendly is in quotes):

[We are] definitely “friendly” to gays and lesbians. We hope to welcome anyone who comes to church wanting to seek or worship Jesus. Where we differ from the churches listed is that we do not affirm a homosexual lifestyle, since we cannot find such an affirmation in Scripture. But I would guess we differ from other churches that [you] may have attended in that we are not condemning of gays or lesbians. As to leadership issues we continue to support the denomination’s current constitutional view: church officers must live in a faithful marriage relationship between a man and a woman, or in chaste singleness. Hope that assists.

Even if the above is clearly not friendly or accepting of my family, it’s a huge positive change for churches and schools to not condemn, and for someone to respond to me instead of ignoring me.  The writer, representing the church, clearly has good decent intentions, if not exactly friendly and welcoming words.

No candles!

photo by Flickr user Stewf

Towards the end of each year, since becoming parents, Moya and I have wondered what to give to the people who teach and take care of our daughter.   In 2005 I asked my favorite former elementary school teacher for suggestions.  She gave me this hilarious compendium:

Here are some of my favorites:
- a letter from a family stating specifically the things I had done that made an impact on their child and/or their family
- gift cards to stores that I use to get things for my classroom (most of these things come out of the teacher’s own pocket).  These would include bookstores (!!! big one !!!), grocery stores, and teaching supply stores.
- movie and restaurant passes, and gift cards for anywhere
- food!  includes chocolates and anything else… at the holidays you need to have stuff around for others, so if you love it you can hide it and eat it all yourself, and otherwise you can share with guests or fellow teachers

Things I would suggest you NOT get (although I can’t imagine you doing these things, but I have gotten multiples of everything on this list!):
- candles
- candles
- candles
- hand lotions in strong smelling scents (who knows what scent another might hate?)
- candles
- bath salts from a strange dad in your class (okay, that only happened once)
- candles
- kleenex (also only once)
- candles
- a free massage from the licensed massage therapist mom in your class – too weird for me, and I never redeemed  (she didn’t learn though, and gave the first grade teacher the same thing the next year)
- candles
- large heavy statues of things like water fountains, angels, and children playing
- candles

Any more suggestions for what to give or not give to all the amazing people who work at our kid’s school?