Category Archives: storytelling

Subway Music and a Funeral

Listening to Natalia Paruz in the subway

Last Thursday (April 29) I went on a Subway Music Tour with the energetic fabulous entertaining interesting artist/illustrator Zina Saunders as a part of the Gel conference (on of my favorite conferences).  The Gel conference is basically a 2day summer camp for adults, only it’s in spring.  This year it was a combination of technology, design, community, social consciousness, military, religion, art, music, politics, robots,  inspiration, joy, whimsy, and some friends I hadn’t seen since last year’s Gel conference.

The conference is just 2 days, with choices of activities on the first day (this year I chose the music tour, and last year I went on an underground tunnel tour in Brooklyn) and an intriguing day of live music and presentations on the second day.

Everyone we talked with who plays in the subway mentioned that it’s a good place to rehearse/practice and, hopefully, make money too, though some of the musicians commented on how much they are ignored by all of the people who walk by.  The Ebony Hillbillies performed at the conference on the second day of the conference and said that they use their subway performance times as rehearsal time/space.

Natalia Paruz

Natalia Paruz was studying to be a dancer when she was in an accident that stopped her dance career.  She saw someone playing the musical saw when she was in Austria and asked how to learn to play it.  She was told to buy a saw at a hardware store and figure it out.  She figured it out!  She straps an iPod to her leg which plays backup music through an amp and a speaker while she plays her saw.  Often people think she’s singing and she has to show them that it’s the saw, not her voice.

One of the musicians we chatted with and listened to was Luke Ryan at grand central station.  He pointed to all of the people who walked by without looking at him and diagnosed and identified and stereotyped them and then mused about the commonalities and correlations between people who listen or stop or talk with subway musicians and those who don’t.  Can Hunch figure out what inspires or motivates someone to listen or stop or talk or give money to a subway musician?  Luke mentioned that he’d like to gather together the 30 or so people who pay attention to him every day and have a banquet — figuring that if they could all sit at a table together, he’d easily figure out what they all have in common. That’d be a fantastic dinner party!

While I was on the plane, flying to NYC for this conference, I received an email that my grandma (my dad’s mom) had died.  Within the next day the funeral had been set for Sunday.  I had plans for Saturday and Sunday in NYC with friends.  By Friday I had decided I’d change my plans, change my plane ticket, buy a new plane ticket, reserve a rental car, and go to my grandma’s funeral.

I hadn’t seen her in a long time (I wasn’t as close to her as I was to my other grandma who died last year).  We exchanged cards and photos at Christmas every year.  She was always kind and gentle.  She made a sock monkey for me as a child that I still have and that my 5 1/2 year old daughter now claims as her own.  She spent almost all of her adult life as a mother, grandmother, great-grandmother, and finally, before she died, a great-great-grandmother.  I loved the huge family gatherings with my dad’s family when I was a kid, with so many cousins and aunts and uncles and chaos and noise and diversity.

Me in tux/ruffles

So I flew home to San Francisco on Saturday (instead of Sunday).  My wife had tickets for the NCLR party that night and left a ticket for me on the counter.  I changed into a tux and a ruffly shirt (in solidarity with Constance McMillen and Ceara Sturgis who were at the party and had suffered discrimination at their high schools due to wearing or wanting to wear a tux).  I checked my wild einstein-curly hair in a mirror and went to find Moya at the party.

My siblings and their spouses and kids

The next morning I put on a black suit and went back to the airport to fly to Portland, Oregon, get a rental car, and drive to the church for the funeral.  All of my aunts and uncles and cousins were there, but my parents weren’t there.  My younger brother read a letter from my dad recanting some sweet stories about my grandma (my dad’s mom).  When my dad was a child, my grandma made him 3 shirts all from the same fabric, so people thought he was always wearing the same shirt, not 3 different shirts that were exactly the same.  After the funeral at the church, there was a drive to a cemetary to bury my grandma, and then a drive back to the church for a meal with everyone.  While sitting at a table with all of my siblings, with relatives and other people stopping by to chat with us, I remembered Luke Ryan’s comment that he’d like to have a banquet table for the 30+ people who stop by every day.  Those 30+ people might not have as much in common as he hopes, or they might.  In a large room in a church with most of my relatives, who I rarely see, I realized we all have our humanity in common, and that’s enough to treat people with graciousness even if they’re nervous around me or ignore me for whatever reason.

How does “sweetie” become shunned?

I’ve been browsing photos that parents have taken of their children.  Captions and titles and comments call these children sweet and cute and adorable and lovely and all sorts of niceties.  I remember those words being applied to me as a child when adults talked about me.  Most of the adults in my life, as a child, were at church.

Kindergarten

Many of those adults now would barely speak to me because I’m a lesbian.  That one word moves me from a sweet lovely adored person included in a community to a shunned “sinner” not worthy of human acknowledgement.

Many of those adults apparently also stopped talking to and including my parents.

I grew up in a very strict lutheran church that is closely related to Laestadian churches.  Women were not allowed to be pastors or ministers.  They participated in discussions at bible studies but they never stood up in the pulpit and spoke to the congregation.  We were required to always wear dresses to church (something my younger sister hated).  Most of the women were housewives and stay at home parents (though that wasn’t my mom or grandma).  Dancing and watching movies/TV were strictly forbidden.  The only music ever played was religious music and hymns.  I was taught that other religions were strictly wrong and that we held the one true truth/faith and were the only people going to heaven.  When friends of my parents divorced, when I was a child, I noticed that the divorced couple did not seem welcome any longer in our church.   Most men smoked heavily, but most women didn’t.  Alcohol was never drunk.

Any wonder I distrust religion?

Remembering

She, the 5 1/2 year old, is shuffling across the floor wearing one of my slippers (I’m wearing the other slipper) and her nightgown. She’s holding a tiny cat on a tiny bag with a large pink plastic ring on her thumb. Her long curly hair is a twisty mess. She’s talking talking talking. I’m wondering how long I’ll remember this charming moment and how long it will be before it becomes a part of the aggregate charming moments (the antidote to the tantrum moments). I’m pretty sure Evernote (where I store all sorts of ideas and stories) won’t exist in 20+ years. Servers and companies and technologies die, become obsolete, so I’m pretty sure it’s all up to my biology to hold onto bits of stories to recant for Lucy when she’s an adult. I don’t want to remember everything. Just a good mixtape for her. I try to focus all of my attention on some moments to help remember it later. One of my parents once told a story about me-as-a-child, in recent years, at a dinner party. It was a story about my sister, not me. I’ve been so perfectly unacknowledged (we have our own don’t ask don’t tell in our family) for so many years that I didn’t correct the story. Moya and Lucy have sharp memories, so between the three of us, SOMEONE will remember.

Crowdsourcing parenting tips

Yesterday marked a year since my grandma died.  After she died, we talked with Lucy about how we keep dead people in our lives by remembering them, telling stories about them, looking at pictures of them, and sometimes seeing them in our dreams.  Lucy was a big fan of her great-grandma.  We took a vacation with my grandma when Lucy was 2 years old — an adventure in balancing the quick (Lucy constantly running) and the slow (grandma) — and Lucy loved the undivided attention that my grandma always devoted to her.

Lucy near her great-grandma's grave in Hopewell, Oregon (March 2009)

After Martin Luther King day this year, Lucy talked about death and how we communicate with and remember dead people.  She wanted to know why a dead person’s birthday is celebrated (MLK) if the dead person isn’t around to eat cake and blow out candles.  Then she wanted to know if we could celebrate her great-grandma’s birthday (since we celebrate MLK’s birthday) and asked if she could send her a letter telling her that she loves her and misses her.  I was stumped — have her write a letter and send it to the cemetary?

I asked for suggestions on Twitter and Facebook (because everyone knows that the answer to any question is on the internet).  I got some great ideas from my brilliant friends (who I didn’t identify here to protect privacy, but if anyone wants attribution for their idea, just poke/ping me):

  • Write the letter and save it. I kept a journal as a kid to keep my neighbor up to date when he died suddenly.
  • Since she’s already felt it in her heart, she’s already sent it
  • The cemetery might work, and you can call first and let them know it’s coming so it wouldn’t be returned to sender. If Lucy’s already ok with the concept that greatgrandma is “dead”, you could address it to the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_letter_office
  • Maybe you could say that when her greatgrandma died, her body went away but she’s still around in spirit because of how much she loved her family, kind of like how Lucy can feel your love for her even if you’re not in the same room. Since she doesn’t get mail any more, the way to send her a letter is to write it out and then burn it and when the smoke rises up, Lucy’s message will be carried to that place where her greatgrandma can read it.
  • 1. Mail it to her with no return address. Greatgrandma c/o The AFTERLIFE 2. Go to the beach or some place special and read the letter out loud to her and then burn it or bury it
  • Be pragmatic and tell her the truth — that life is without meaning and there is no point in anything…just kidding :-)
  • Oh Lucy I wish we could write to the dead but they are gone so they cannot get mail, but we can always keep them in our thoughts and deeds, like Dr King. And in a way they are always with us.
  • Ask her if she remembers what it was like before she was born. Tell her that’s where Grandma is.
  • I like the idea of her writing an actual letter. Maybe you could find a place meaningful to share it? My mom and stepdad have two trees (one for his mother, one for one of his daughters) and my mom has a birdbath as their spots. Maybe Lucy can find something that becomes a sharing spot and a box she/you can make that is her mailbox. That way, she can write the letter, she knows her grandmother won’t literally receive it, but if she can symbolically send it.
  • I also like the idea of her writing the letter. But I’d hold onto it in case she wants to see it later. No point lying about doing that either. Perhaps you can say “You should write the letter and when you are happy with the words, we’ll put it in a special place and if the letter can get to her, it will. Someday you can go back and look at them too. The important thing is what you want to say and how you feel because even if your great grandma gets the letter, she can’t just write back.”
  • It’s a lovely idea to write the letter and then save it for her to read later. If she really wants to send it……then I guess you have to be honest and tell her that nobody really knows where people go after they die. It’s one of the great mysteries of life.

As of today the letter hasn’t been written and she hasn’t brought it up again, but Lucy remembers everything and I know she’ll ask about it again soon.

I get the best advice from the internet.